Exhibits

Exhibits (other than confidential exhibits) received by the Commission will be available for downloading from this page.

Exhibit 511 : Report – Ward Work Allocation Report – Intensive Care Unit – dated 18/10/2004

Exhibit 510 :
(A) Email - Terry HANELT to Kees NYDAM – dated 12 March 2003 re: Clinical Privileges
(B) Letter – Mike ALLSOPP to Dr D KRISHNA – undated – re: Clinical Privileges
(C) Letter – Mike ALLSOPP to Dr D KRISHNA – dated 13 January 2003 - re: Clinical Privileges

Exhibit 509 : Statement – Ms Gail DOHERTY – dated 20 May 2005 plus attachment GD1 - [Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7399]

Exhibit 508 : Statement – Ms Karen JENNER – dated 19 May 2005 plus attachment KJ1 - [Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7382]

Exhibit 507 : Statement – Ms Margaret MEARS – dated 17 May 2005
[Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7374]

Exhibit 506 : Affidavit – Mr Ian BROWN – dated 25 October 2005
[Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7373]

Exhibit 505 :
(A) Letter – Mr Peter DWYER to Mr Richard DOUGLAS SC – dated 21 October 2005 - re: Commonwealth funding for elective surgery
(B) Statement – Michael ZANCO – dated 20 October 2005 plus attachments MCZ-A, MCZ-B, MCZ-C
[Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7373]

Exhibit 504 : Statement – Dr Morgan NAIDOO – dated 21 October 2005 plus attachments MNN-1 to MNN-3 & MNN-4 to MNN-7
[Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7373]

Exhibit 503 : Letter – Dr David MORGAN to Commissioner Davies AO re: Fraser Coast Health Service – Hervey Bay Hospital – dated 24 October 2005 - [Transcript : 27/10/2005 @ Page 7373]

Exhibit 502 : Bundle of 22 minutes of meetings – Fraser Coast Health Service Management Advisory Group – Surgical Services – 30 January 2002 until 14 May 2004 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7365]

Exhibit 501 : Email – Darren KEATING to Gail DOHERTY – CC Jayant PATEL and Karen SMITH - dated 8 February 2005 @ 4.01pm re: Theatre activities - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7355]

Exhibit 500 : Supplementary Statement - Ms Linda MULLIGAN - dated 21 October 2005 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7355]

Exhibit 499 : Statement - Dr David LITTLE - dated 31 September 2005 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7355]

Exhibit 498 : Letter – Dr Peter WOODRUFF to QPHCI – dated 20 October 2005 re: bile duct surgery - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7352]

Exhibit 497 : Statement - Monica SETH – dated 14 October 2005 plus attachments MS-1 & MS-2 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7351]

Exhibit 496 : Schedule – Dr NAIDOO’s petrol purchases – A STELLA - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7351]

Exhibit 495 : Statement - Leslie WENBAN – dated 13 October 2005 plus attachments LW1 & LW2, LW3 & LW4, LW5 & LW6, LW7, LW8, LW9 & LW10, LW11 & LW12, LW13, LW14, LW15
[Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7351]

Exhibit 494 : Statement - Dianne JENKIN – dated 7 July 2005 plus attachments DJJ-1 to DJJ-4 and DJJ-5 to DJJ-16 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7350]

Exhibit 493 : Ministerial Briefing – BR021399 – Subject: Advice regarding patients who died whilst on Waiting List at The Prince Charles Hospital – dated 25 October 2004 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7350]

Exhibit 492 : Statement - Brian William JOHNSTON – dated 17 October 2005 plus attachments BWJ1, BWJ2, BWJ3 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7350]

Exhibit 491 : Statement - Meagan SNELL – dated 10 August 2005 plus attachment MS-1 to MS-6 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7350]

Exhibit 490 : Statement – Dr Richard ASHBY – dated 19 August 2005 plus attachments RA-1 & RA-2 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7349]

Exhibit 489 : Statement – Professor Leonie HOBBS – dated 19 July 2005 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7349]

Exhibit 488 : Statement – Dinah MUNROE – dated 14 July 2005 plus attachments DM1 & DM2 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7349]

Exhibit 487 :
(A) Letter – D Atkinson to P Dwyer – dated 12 October 2005;
(B) Letter – P Dwyer to D Atkinson dated 20 October 2005;
(C) Supplementary Statement of Dr Kees NYDAM – dated 19 October 2005
[Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7349]

Exhibit 486 : Statements
(A) Statement - Therese Francis WINSTON - dated 4 July 2005 plus CV & attachments TW1 to TW8;
(B) Supplementary Statement – Therese Francis WINSTON - dated 7 October 2005
[Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7348]

Exhibit 485 : Supplementary statement – Ms Karen FOX – dated 3 October 2005 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7348]

Exhibit 484 : Statement – Dr Anatole Kotlovsky – dated 14 October 2005 plus attachments 1 to 12 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7348]

Exhibit 483 : Supplementary Statement - Gail DOHERTY – dated 7 October 2005 - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7347]

Exhibit 482 : Statement - Dr Anthony WILSON - dated 11 October 2005 including attachments A & B - [Transcript : 21/10/2005 @ Page 7328]

Exhibit 481 : Sentinal Event Report Form - Bundaberg Health Service District - [Transcript : 19/10/2005 @ Page 7316]

Exhibit 480 : Bundle of 6 letters - dated from December 1997 to October 1999 - [Transcript : 19/10/2005 @ Page 7316]

Exhibit 479 : Email - Linda MULLIGAN to Peter LECK - dated 13 January 2005 @ 4:35pm re: fwd: Day Report
[Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7282]

Exhibit 478 : Bundle of minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District
(A) Executive Council minutes of 5 March 2004
(B) Executive Council minutes of 2 April 2004
(C) Executive Council minutes of 7 May 2004
(D) Leadership and Management Minutes of 31 May 2004
(E) Executive Council minutes of 4 June 2004
(F) Executive Council minutes of 2 July 2004
(G) Executive Council minutes of 3 Spetember 2004
(H) ASPIC Clinical Service Forum minutes 18 August 2004
(I) Finance Committee minutes 17 September 2004
(J) Leadership and Management Minutes of 27 September 2004
(K) Executive Council minutes of 1 October 2004
(L) Leadership and Management Minutes of 18 October 2004
(M) Finance Committee minutes 22 October 2004
(N) Leadership and Management Minutes of 1 November 2004
(O) Executive Council minutes of 12 November 2004
(P) Leadership and Management minutes of 15 November 2004
(Q) Finance Committee minutes of 19 November 2004
(R) Leadership and Management Minutes of 8 December 2004
(S) Finance Committee minutes of 21 January 2005
(T) Leadership and Management minutes of 24 January 2005
(U) Leadership and Management minutes of 31 January 2005
(V) Executive Council minutes of 4 February 2005
(W) Executive Council minutes 4 March 2005
[Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7278]

Exhibit 477 : Email – Peter LECK to Dan BERGIN – dated 7 April 2005 @ 7.15pm re: Leaking of Confidential Information re Patel - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 72127]

Exhibit 476 : Email – Dan BERGIN to Peter LECK – dated 7 April 2005 @ 5.13pm re: Leaking of Confidential Information re Patel - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7210]

Exhibit 475 : Email – Peter LECK to Dan BERGIN and Paul MICHAELS - dated 24 March 2005 @ 1.35 pm re: Dr Jay Patel - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7209]

Exhibit 474 : Email – Peter LECK to SDLO CC: Dan BERGIN – dated 23 March 2005 @ 5.47pm re: letter to the editor – Bundaberg Newsmail - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7208]

Exhibit 473 : Newspaper article – Bundaberg Newsmail – dated 28 March 2005 – titled “Backed by the Executive” - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7207]

Exhibit 472 : Email – Peter LECK to SDLO – CC Dan BERGIN and Paul MICHAELS - dated 22 March 2005 @ 20.19 re: Dr Jay Patel - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7203]

Exhibit 471 : Email exchange – Karen SMITH to “Executive + Nums” – dated 13 January 2005 @ 3.31pm and forwarded by Peter LECK to Linda MULLIGAN – dated 13 January 2005 @ 4.08pm re: Day Report - [Transcript : 18/10/2005 @ Page 7179]

Exhibit 470 : Email – Peter LECK to Darren KEATING – dated 21 December 2004 @ 2.04pm re: night report - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7172]

Exhibit 469 : Letter – Medical Board of Queensland to Dr J PATEL – dated 1 April 2003 – CC: Medical Superintendent/Manager, Bundaberg Base Hospital re: grant of special purpose registration - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7144]

Exhibit 468 : Excerpts – Dr NOTHLING’s report – dated 22 September 2005 @ pp.5 and 11 - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7133]

Exhibit 467 : Service Agreement 2004/05 – Bundaberg Health Service District, Queensland Health - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7128]

Exhibit 466 : Service Agreement 2003/04 – Bundaberg Health Service District, Queensland Health - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7123]

Exhibit 465 : Service Agreement 2002/03 – Central Zone Management Unit, Bundaberg Health Service District, Queensland Health - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7122]

Exhibit 464 : QPHCI Chronology – Peter LECK
[Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7119]

Exhibit 463 : Statement – Peter LECK – dated 11 May 2005
[Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7119]

Exhibit 462 : Supplementary statement - Michael Carlo ZANCO - dated 4 Oct 2005 - plus attachments MCZ1 & MCZ2
[Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7117]

Exhibit 461 : Affidavit – James Patrick O’DEMPSEY – dated 14 October 2005 – plus attachments JPO1, JPO2, JPO3, JPO4, JPO5, JPO6, JPO7, JPO8, JPO9, JPO10, JPO11, JPO12, JPO13, JPO14, JPO15, JPO16A to JPO16U, JPO17A to JPO17K, JPO18, JPO19, JPO20, JPO21 - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7116]

Exhibit 460 : Excerpts - Corporate Office Document Management Documentation:
(A) Document Registration: Data Entry Standards - undated;
(B) Executive Management and Support Executive Document Management System Data Entry Guidelines - March 1998;
(C) Executive Services Guidelines – July 1999;
(D) Executive Services Guidelines – March 2002;
(E) Executive Services Unit Work Flows and Business Processes – 15 March 2003;
(F) Executive Services Executive Support Unit Electronic Procedure Index and Manual – 26 September 2003;
[Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7105]

Exhibit 459 : Supplementary Statement - Dr Stephen Michael BUCKLAND - dated 7 October 2005 - [Transcript : 17/10/2005 @ Page 7099]

Exhibit 458 : Supplementary Statement – Dr Gerard FITZGERALD – dated 11 September 2005 - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7096]

Exhibit 457 : Sponsorship for temporary residence documents:
(A) Letter – Majella GALWAY to Clare MURPHY – dated 13 October;
(B) Letter – Clare MURPHY to Majella GALWAY – dated 13 October;
(C) Summons to Produce – to Majella GALWAY - dated 13 October;
(D) Form 55 – Application by Dr KEATING for sponsorship for temporary residence in Australia of Dr PATEL – dated 1 February 2005 - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7096]

Exhibit 456 : Statement - Mr Michael ALLSOPP – dated 27 July 2005 - plus attachments MA1 to MA5 & MA6 to MA18 - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7093]

Exhibit 455 : Application for Clinical Privileges (Specialists) – by Jayant PATEL - for the position of Director of Surgery, Bundaberg Hospital - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7068]

Exhibit 454 : Transcript (QPHCI) – excerpts – evidence of Dr KEATING - pp 6874-6875 and pp 6880-6883 - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7058]

Exhibit 453 : Email exchange – Peter LECK to Gerry FITZGERALD – between 7 February 2005 @ 2.35pm and February 2005 @ 4.50pm - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7025]

Exhibit 452 : Email exchange – Peter LECK to Darren KEATING – between 26 October 2004 @ 5:45pm and 27 October 2004 @ 8:57am re: meeting with medical staff about allegations - [Transcript : 13/10/2005 @ Page 7025]

Exhibit 451 : Letter – Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs to Dr Darren KEATING - dated 14 February 2005 re: Sponsorship 422 lodged by Bundaberg Health Service District - [Transcript : 12/10/2005 @ Page 6919]

Exhibit 450 : Letter – Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs to Dr Darren KEATING - dated 15 December 2003 re: Sponsorship 422 lodged by Bundaberg Health Service District - [Transcript : 12/10/2005 @ Page 6918]

Exhibit 449 : Email exchange – Peter LECK to John SCOTT – between 13 January 2005 @ 10:39am and 20 January 2005 @ 8:41am - [Transcript : 12/10/2005 @ Page 6917]

Exhibit 448 : Statement - Dr Darren William KEATING - dated 6 October 2005 - plus attachments DWK1, DWK2, DWK3, DWK4, DWK5, DWK6, DWK7, DWK8, DWK9, DWK10, DWK11, DWK12, DWK13, DWK14, DWK15, DWK16, DWK17, DWK18, DWK19, DWK20, DWK21, DWK22, DWK23, DWK24, DWK25, DWK26, DWK27, DWK28, DWK29, DWK30, DWK31, DWK32, DWK33, DWK34, DWK35, DWK36, DWK37, DWK38, DWK38A, DWK39, DWK40, DWK41, DWK42, DWK43, DWK44, DWK45, DWK46, DWK47, DWK48, DWK49, DWK50, DWK51, DWK52, DWK53, DWK54, DWK55, DWK56, DWK57, DWK58, DWK59, DWK60, DWK61, DWK62, DWK63, DWK64, DWK65, DWK66, DWK67, DWK68, DWK69, DWK70, DWK71, DWK72, DWK73, DWK74, DWK75, DWK76, DWK77, DWK78, DWK79, DWK80, DWK81, DWK82, DWK83, DWK84, DWK85, DWK86, DWK87, DWK88, DWK89 - [Transcript : 11/10/2005 @ Page 6809]

Exhibit 447 : Registration documents - Dr Dinesh SHARMA:
Application for Area of Need Certification - dated 14 January 2003; Medical Board of Queensland Certificate of Registration, Special Purpose, Section 135 – for the period 27 February 2003 to 25 January 2004; Application for Area of Need Certification - dated 12 November 2003; Certificate of Registration, Special Purpose, Section 135 – for the period 26 January 2004 to 25 January 2005; Certificate of Registration, Special Purpose, Section 135 – for the period 17 January 2005 to 16 January 2006 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6780]

Exhibit 446 : Registration documents - Dr Damodaran KRISHNA:
Position Description-Senior Medical Officer-Orthopaedics – dated February 2002; Application for Area of Need Certification - dated 22 May 2002; Medical Board of Queensland Certificate of Registration – dated 28 June 2002; Application for Area of Need Certification - dated 24 April 2003; Certificate of Registration, Special Purpose, Section 135 – for the period 18 July 2003 to 17 July 2004; Form 1, “Area of Need” Position Description - dated 11 May 2004; Certificate of Registration, Special Purpose, Section 135 – for the period 18 July 2004 to 17 July 2005; Medical Board of Queensland, Assessment Form, Special Purpose Registrants - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6780]

Exhibit 445 : Form 1 – “Area of Need” Position Description – for applicant Dr Damodaran KRISHNA – signed by Terry HANELT (said to be created approx April 2003) - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6721]

Exhibit 444 : Statements – Dr Terrence Michael HANELT:
(A) dated 18 August 2005 plus attachments TMH-1 to TMH19 & TMH-20 to TMH-37
(B) dated 7 October 2005 including attachments A & B , C , D-F
[Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6714]

Exhibit 443 : Progress notes excerpt – re: patient P450 – dated 15-17 June 2004 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6691]

Exhibit 442 : Discharge Summary – Dr KRISHNA re: patient P450 – dated 17 June 2004 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6688]

Exhibit 441 : Orthopaedic Discharge Summary – Dr NAIDOO re: patient P450– dated 29 June 2004 (for discharge 17 June 2004) - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6688]

Exhibit 440 : Supplementary statement – Dr Morgan Neelan NAIDOO – dated 10 October 2005 inlcuding attachments MNN-1 to MNN-5 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6679]

Exhibit 439 : Statement – Andrew CHRISTENSEN – dated 10 October 2005 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6679]

Exhibit 438 : Certificates of Registration – Special Purpose – Section 135 re: Dinesh Chandra Prasad SHARMA – for the period 17 January 2005 to 16 January 2006 and Damodaran KRISHNA – for the period 18 July 2003 to 17 July 2004 - [Transcript : 10/10/2005 @ Page 6677]

Exhibit 437 : Statement - Dr Christopher Martin JELLIFFE - dated 6 October 2005 - [Transcript : 7/10/2005 @ Page 6648]

Exhibit 436 : Sydney Sax Medal - Public Health Association of Australia - Information package and nomination of Dr John SCOTT - [Transcript : 7/10/2005 @ Page 6646]

Exhibit 435 : Mobile Telephone records – Dr Morgan NAIDOO – dated January 2004 – January 2005
[Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6619]

Exhibit 434 : Bundle of memoranda – Leave arrangements for Dr NAIDOO - dated 2 October 2002 (4 memoranda); 2 December 2003; 12 December 2003; 1 July 2004; 21 October 2004; 30 November 2004; 31 January 2005 (2 memoranda)
[Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6610]

Exhibit 433 : Summary – Orthopaedic Surgery performed from 17/7/02 to 19/11/03 re: Dr D KRISHNA - [Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6604]

Exhibit 432 : Leave records - Dr Morgan Neelan NAIDOO:
(A) Queensland Health records – printed 28 September 2005
(B) QPHCI “Summary of leave taken by Dr NAIDOO - [Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6590]

Exhibit 431 : Statement – Dr Morgan Neelan NAIDOO – dated 28 September 2005 – plus attachments MNN-1 to MNN-4 & MNN-5 to MNN-7 - [Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6588]

Exhibit 430 : Notice of Potential Adverse Recommendations – Dr Jayant Mukundray PATEL:
(A) Letter – QPHCI to Dr PATEL, C/O Quinn and Scattini, Lawyers - dated 26 September 2005 re: Notice of Potential Adverse recommendations;
(B) Letter – Quinn and Scattini (Lawyers for Dr PATEL) to QPHCI – dated 5 October 2005
[Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6586]

Exhibit 429 : Bundle of memoranda – Queensland Health re: Elective Surgery (BUC.0001.0018.00252-263, 271-278 plus 2 pages not numbered) - [Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6570]

Exhibit 428 : Memorandum – General Manager (Health Services) to District manager, Princes Alexandra Hospital and Health Service District, copies to Zonal Manager – dated 21 August 2003 re: “Elective Surgery and Total Surgery Targets 2002/03 - [Transcript : 6/10/2005 @ Page 6565]

Exhibit 427 : Supplementary statement – titled “Answers of Dr Glenn Philip CUFFE to schedule 2 Questions” - dated 5 October 2005 – plus attachments GPC-2 to GPC-4 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6536]

Exhibit 426 : Statement – Glenn CUFFE – dated 2 October 2005 including attachment GPC-1 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6536]

Exhibit 425 : Statement – Cheryl BRENNAN – dated 29 September 2005 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6534]

Exhibit 424 : Statement – Dr Damodaran KRISHNA - dated 28 July 2005 – plus attachments DK-1 to DK-3 & DK-4 to DK-9 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6465]

Exhibit 423 : Statement – Dr Sharyn SMITH – dated 3 October 2005 and attachment (Critical Care Retrieval Services – Clinical Coordination Form – dated 27 July 2004 - plus patient notes re: patient Desmond BRAMICH) - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6463]

Exhibit 422 : Royal Flying Doctor Service records re: patient Desmond BRAMICH: including bundle of emails and patient records - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6463]

Exhibit 421 : Statement – Ainslie McMULLEN – dated 27 June 2005 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6463]

Exhibit 420 : Supplementary Affidavit – Michael Steven DEMY-GEROE – dated 3 October 2005 - plus attachment MDG-1 - [Transcript : 5/10/2005 @ Page 6462]

Exhibit 419 : Endorsement – by TM to Mr Gary WALKER - dated 7 October 2003 (on Fax header attaching file note re: Mackay Elective Surgery) - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6447]

Exhibit 418 : Spreadsheets – Surgical Inpatient Activity Reports – Sunshine Coast, Queensland Health – dated 31 December 2002 and 1 July 2003 - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6443]

Exhibit 417 : Statements – Mr Colin ROBERTS
(A) dated 30 September 2005
(B) dated 3 October 2005
[Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6432]

Exhibit 416 : Statement – Deborah Faye MILLER – dated 4 October 2005 plus attachments DFM-1 to DFM-3, DFM-4, DFM-5 to DFM-11
[Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6407]

Exhibit 415 : Bundle of Minutes: Meeting of Theatre Utilisation Project – dated 1 October 2001 @ 14.10hrs; Meeting of Medical Staff Advisory Committee – dated 13 November 2001 @ 7.00hrs; Meeting of Medical Staff Advisory Committee – dated 13 August 2002 @ 7.00hrs; Meeting of Medical Staff Advisory Committee – dated 1o September 2002 @ 7.10hrs (noted “Amended 12 September 2002”); Meeting of Medical Staff Advisory Committee – dated 8 October 2002 @ 7.05hrs
[Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6405]

Exhibit 414 : Letter – Ms Georgie ROSE, Human Resource Manager, Bundaberg Health Service District, to Dr BAKER - dated 12 June 2002 re: “Formal offer of a position with the Bundaberg Health Service District” - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6398]

Exhibit 413 : Letter – Dr BAKER to Mr Peter LECK – dated 6 May 2002 re: resignation - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6397]

Exhibit 412 : Letter - Mr Peter LECK, District Manager, Bundaberg Health Service District, to Dr BAKER - dated 30 November 2004 re: “Confidential” - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6396]

Exhibit 411 : Business Case – Operating Theatre Utilisation Bundaberg Health Service District – dated 3 September 2005
[Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6361]

Exhibit 410 : Statement – Samuel Patrick BAKER – dated 4 October 2005 plus attachments SPB1 to SPB11 & SPB12 to SPB15 - [Transcript : 4/10/2005 @ Page 6346]

Exhibit 409 : File note - Dr CRAWFORD re: "P446" – dated 13 August 2005 plus two Operation Notes re: "P446"
[Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6311]

Exhibit 408 : Letters – Dr CRAWFORD to Dr SENIOR - dated 10 June 2005 and 30 August 2005 re: “P445”
[Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6308]

Exhibit 407 : Letter – Dr CRAWFORD to Dr GOLDSTON re: "P444" - dated 10 June 2005 - [Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6307]

Exhibit 406 : Letters – Dr CRAWFORD to Dr OGUNSEYE - dated 24 June 2005 and 7 September 2005 re: “P443”
[Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6305]

Exhibit 405 : Letter - Dr Scott CRAWFORD to Dr G MALHERBE – dated 10 June 2005 re: "P442"
[Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6300]

Exhibit 404 : Statement – Scott Andrew CRAWFORD – dated 16 September 2005 - [Transcript : 3/10/2005 @ Page 6294]

Exhibit 403 : Letter – Dr Con ARONEY to Gloria WALLACE, District Manager, Prince Charles Hospital – dated 9 March 2005 re: letter of resignation [Transcript: 30/09/2005 @ Page 6288]

Exhibit 402 : Letter – Hon Premier to Commissioner Davies – dated 30 September 2005 – attaching letter from Premier to Minster Robertson – dated 30 September 2005 re: Elective Surgery Program - [Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6285]

Exhibit 401 : Letter – Medical Staff Association to Ms Deborah PODBURY, District Manager, Prince Charles Hospital re: support for Dr Darren Walters - [Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6240]

Exhibit 400 : Statement – Helen Charmaine BEH – dated 30 May 2005 – including attachments
[Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6238]

Exhibit 399 : Statement – Martin ROLLINGS – dated 2 September 2005 - plus attachments MR-1 to MR-2
[Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6237]

Exhibit 398 : Memorandum - General Manager (Health Services) to District Managers and copies to Zonal Managers re: Elective Surgery and Total Surgery Targets 2002/03
[Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6235]

Exhibit 397 : Briefing to General Manager (Health Services) – Queensland Health re: Emergency Re-classification – dated 8 October 2003 - [Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6228]

Exhibit 396 : Briefing to General Manager (Health Services) – Queensland Health re: Classification of Emergency and Elective Surgery – dated 8 September 2003
[Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6223]

Exhibit 395 : Submission to General Manager (Health Services) – Queensland Health re: Retention of Quarantined Elective Surgery Funds – dated 11 September 2003
[Transcript : 30/09/2005 @ Page 6222]

Exhibit 394 : Original copy of Exhibit 368 - Submission – Queensland Health re: Re-classification of Emergency Presentations as Elective Surgery – dated 30 July 2003
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6198]

Exhibit 393 : Supplementary statement – Gary WALKER – dated 27 September 2005 plus attachments GW-35 to GW-36
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6172]

Exhibit 392 : Bundle of draft versions – Exhibit 230: Clinical Audit of General Surgical Services - dated March 2005
Copy 1 Date Modified Tuesday 22 February 2005, 4:55pm
Copy 2 Date Modified Thursday 10 March 2005, 12:43pm
Copy 3 Date Modified Tuesday 22 March 2005, 4:52pm
Copy 4 Date Modified Thursday 24 March 2005, 3:52pm
Copy 5 Date Modified Thursday 24 March 2005, 3:07pm
Copy 6 Date Modified Thursday 29 March 2005, 1:36pm
Copy 7 Date Modified Wednesday 1 June 2005, 2:23pm
Appendix - A1 Date Modified Monday 11 April 2005, 4:31pm
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6166]

Exhibit 391 : Email – Gerry FITZGERALD to SDLO – dated 22 March 2005 @ 1.25pm – attaching suggested response to Parliamentary question re: “Surgical Services at Bundaberg Hospital”
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6194]

Exhibit 390 : Letter – Hunt and Hunt to Secretary, Commission of Inquiry – dated 27 September 2005 re: “Our client: Mr Peter Leck” - [Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6092]

Exhibit 389 : Medical reports – re: Mr Peter LECK:
(A) Dr Jeremy BUTLER dated 8 June 2005
(B) Dr Jeremy BUTLER dated 20 June 2005
(C) Dr Jeremy BUTLER dated 17 August 2005
(D) Dr Jeremy BUTLER dated 14 September 2005
(E) Excerpt report by Dr Martin NOTHLING dated 22 September 2005
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6091]

Exhibit 388 : Letter – Premier to Commissioner Davies – undated (received 29 September 2005) re: indication of possible findings
[Transcript : 29/09/2005 @ Page 6091]

Exhibit 387 : Statement – Michael John CLARE – dated 27 September 2005 - [Transcript : 28/09/2005 @ Page 6076]

Exhibit 386 : Submissions – on behalf of Mr LECK – dated 28 September 2005 - [Transcript : 28/09/2005 @ Page 6071]

Exhibit 385 : Report – 2005 Measured Quality Service Report for the Bundaberg Health Service District – dated 9 July 2005
[Transcript : 28/09/2005 @ Page 6066]

Exhibit 384 : Briefing Note - A Briefing to the General Manager Health Services - re: Classification and retrospective reclassification of elective surgery patients with a source of referral code, Emergency Department - [Transcript : 27/09/2005 @ Page 6020]

Exhibit 383 : Statement – Dan BERGIN – dated 21 September 2005 plus attachments 1 to 13 - [Transcript : 27/09/2005 @ Page 5985]

Exhibit 382 : Letter – Premier to Commissioner Davies AO – dated 26 September 2005 re: terms of reference and Rockhampton Hospital - [Transcript : 27/09/2005 @ Page 5985]

Exhibit 381 : Addendum statement – Lakshman Kumar JAYASEKERA – dated 27 September 2005
[Transcript : 27/09/2005 @ Page 5963]

Exhibit 380 : Letter – Premier to Commissioner Davies AO – dated 26 September 2005 re: requirement for approval by Premier for any instructions or advice being delivered in his name - [Transcript : 27/09/2005 @ Page 5960]

Exhibit 379 : Report comparison – 2 versions of Exhibit 352:
(A) “Queensland Hospitals in the 21 st Century: A first report” – dated June 2002;
(B) “Queensland Hospitals in the 21 st Century – Leading the Way” – dated June 2003 - [Transcript: 26/09/2005 @ Page 5939]

Exhibit 378 : Statement - Justin Edward COLLINS - dated 23 September 2005 plus attachments JEC27, JEC28, JEC29, JEC30, JEC31, JEC32, JEC33, JEC34, JEC35, JEC36, JEC37, JEC38, JEC39, JEC40, JEC41, JEC42, JEC43A, JEC43B
[Transcript : 26/09/2005 @ Page 5902]

Exhibit 377 : Statement - Justin Edward COLLINS - dated 19 September 2005 plus attachments JEC1, JEC2, JEC3, JEC4, JEC5, JEC6, JEC7, JEC8, JEC9A, JEC9B, JEC9C, JEC9D, JEC10, JEC11, JEC12, JEC13, JEC14, JEC15A, JEC15B, JEC16, JEC17, JEC18, JEC19, JEC20, JEC21, JEC22, JEC23, JEC24, JEC25, JEC26
[Transcript : 26/09/2005 @ Page 5902]

Exhibit 376 : Correspondence – re: Vincent BERG matter: [Transcript : 26/09/2005 @ Page 5900]
(A) Letter - Damien Atkinson, Counsel Assisting to Peter Dwyer, Crown Law re: "Dr Buckland";
(B) Letter - Peter Dwyer , Crown Law to Damien Atkinson, Consel Assisting re: "Dr Buckland - Berg matter";
(C) Statement of Peggy Brown – dated 21 September 2005;
(D) Email from Peter Dwyer to Damien Atkinson - dated 24 September 2005 @ 2.16pm re: Berg issue

Exhibit 375 : Letter – Premier to Commissioner Davies – dated 26 September 2005 re: hospital performance reports - [Transcript : 26/09/2005 @ Page 5851]

Exhibit 374 : Order in Council – Commissions of Inquiry Amendment Order (No.1) 2005 - re: Amendments to Terms of Reference (Commission of Inquiry Order (No.2) 2005 - [Transcript : 26/09/2005 @ Page 5851]

Exhibit 373 : Confidential hospital records relating to P430, P434, P435 and P436 - [Transcript : 23/09/2005 @ Page 5848]

Exhibit 372 : Minutes – Meeting of 16 January 2004 - Fraser Coast Health Service - [Transcript : 23/09/2005 @ Page 5847]

Exhibit 371 : Confidential Patient notes – Hervey Bay Hospital - [Transcript : 23/09/2005 @ Page 5819]

Exhibit 370 : Confidential Patient notes – referred to in the evidence of Dr MULLEN - [Transcript : 23/09/2005 @ Page 5782]

Exhibit 369 : Correspondence – re: Terms of reference and Rockhampton Hospital - [Transcript : 23/09/2005 @ Page 5764]
(A) email exchange from Narelle Dean to Commissioner Davies dated 20 September 2005 @ 1.26pm (forwarding emails to the Premier of 15 September @ 11.54am and to Robert Schwarten MP, Member for Rockhampton of 19 September 2005 @ 1.58pm);
(B) letter from Commissioner Davies AO to the Premier dated 21 September 2005 and draft email to;
(C) email from Commissioner Davies to Narelle Dean

Exhibit 368 : Submission – Queensland Health re: Re-classification of Emergency Presentations as Elective Surgery – dated 30 July 2003 - [Transcript : 22/09/2005 @ Page 5731]

Exhibit 367 : Briefing Note – A Briefing to the Director-General, Queensland Health – dated 10 January 2001 re: “Elective Surgery Activity vs Funding 1996/97 – 1999/2000” - [Transcript : 22/09/2005 @ Page 5728]

Exhibit 366 : Statement – Professor Robert Lynton STABLE – dated 16 September 2005 – including attachments RLS-1 to RLS-7 - [Transcript : 22/09/2005 @ Page 5717]

Exhibit 365 : Schedule – Orthopaedic Surgical Services – Dr Sharma - Scope of Service – (A) “Orthopaedic Trauma” and (B) “Elective Orthopaedic Surgery” – both dated January 2003 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5710]

Exhibit 364 : Schedule – Orthopaedic Surgical Services – Dr Sharma - Scope of Service (A) “Orthopaedic Trauma” and (B) “Elective Orthopaedic Surgery” – both dated January 2004 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5709]

Exhibit 363 : Registration Checklist – Applicants Applying under section 135 to fill an ‘Area of Need’ – dated 17 February 2003 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5703]

Exhibit 362 : Form 1 – “Area of need” Position Description re: Dr Dinesh SHARMA – dated 12 April 2003; and Form 2 – Summary of Experience suitable to Area of Need - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5693]

Exhibit 361 : Form 1 – “Area of need” Position Description re: Dr Dinesh SHARMA – undated; and Form 2 – Summary of Experience suitable to Area of Need - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5692]

Exhibit 360 : Assessment Form – Special Purpose Registrants – completed by Dr NAIDOO for registrant Dr SHARMA – dated 16 June 2005 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5681]

Exhibit 359 : Letter – Registrar, Medical Board of Queensland to Dr SHARMA – CC: Medical Superintendent / Manager, Fraser Coast Health Service District – dated 13 March 2003 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5679]

Exhibit 358 : Information Notice – Deputy Registrar, Medical Board of Queensland to Dr SHARMA re: Decision to Register as a General Registrant on Supervised Practice Program Conditions – ­dated 29 June 2005 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5677]

Exhibit 357 : Statement – Dr Dinesh SHARMA – dated 27 July 2005 – plus attachments DS-1 to DS-14 - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5672]

Exhibit 356 : Letter – Premier to Commissioner Davies AO – dated 20 September 2005 - re: Response to media reports of alleged cover-up - [Transcript : 21/09/2005 @ Page 5671]

Exhibit 355 : Draft report – “Bundaberg Base Hospital – Review of Systemic Issues” - Health Rights Commission - [Transcript : 20/09/2005 @ Page 5642]

Exhibit 354 : Statement – Dr David Arthur KERSLAKE – dated 19 September 2005 – plus attachments DK-1 to DK-3, DK-4 & DK-5 - [Transcript : 20/09/2005 @ Page 5633]

Exhibit 353 : Statement – Dr Mark Peter MATTIUSSI – dated 18 July 2005 – plus attachments MPM-1 to MPM-2 - [Transcript : 20/09/2005 @ Page 5595]

Exhibit 352 : Report – “Queensland Hospitals in the 21 st Century– Leading the Way - Queensland Health" – dated June 2003 - [Transcript : 20/09/2005 @ Page 5592]

Exhibit 351 : Bundle of correspondence -
(A) letter from Mr Springborg MP, Leader of the Opposition, to Commissioner Davies AO dated 12 September 2005;
(B) letter from Commissioner Davies AO to the Premier dated 12 September 2005 ;
(C) letter from Commissioner Davies AO to Mr Springborg MP dated 12 September 2005;
(D) letter from Commissioner Davies AO to the Premier dated 19 September 2005;
(E) letter from Commissioner Davies AO to Mr Springborg MP dated 19 September 2005
[Transcript : 20/09/2005 @ Page 5579]

Exhibit 350 : Ministerial Briefing - BR022137 - "Bundaberg Health Service District and Dr Patel" - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5555]

Exhibit 349 : Affidavit of Dr Lloyd TOFT - dated 12 August 2005 plus Curriculum vitae - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5553]

Exhibit 348 : Business Rules – Queensland Health – “Elective Surgery Business Rules 2003/04 – Surgical Access Service – Waiting List Reduction Strategy” dated 24 October 2003 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5550]

Exhibit 347 : Business Rules – Queensland Health – “Elective Surgery Business Rules 2002/03 – Surgical Access Service – Waiting List Reduction Strategy” dated 9 October 2002 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5547]

Exhibit 346 : Issues Report – Waiting List Reduction Strategy – by Medical Superintendents’ Advisory Committee – dated May 2002 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5546]

Exhibit 345 : Memorandum - To District & Zonal Managers from Dr BUCKLAND re: Elective Surgery Performance - dated 19 October 2000 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5544]

Exhibit 344 : Notes – Program Area Update and Progress – headed “Justin’s (COLLINS) notes” - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5536]

Exhibit 343 : Minutes – Board Meeting of the Measured Quality Program Area – held 11 March 2003 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5533]

Exhibit 342 : Ministerial Briefing Note - Queensland Health re: “Measured Quality Hospital Reports (Phase 2)” - Briefing Note No. BR018109 – dated 10 March 2003 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5532]

Exhibit 341 : Issues Briefing Request Form - Queensland Health re: “Measured Quality Hospital Reports (Phase 2)” - Briefing Note No. BR018109 – dated 7 March 2003 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5530]

Exhibit 340 : Email – Brad SMITH to Dr Robert Stable, Glenn Cuffe, Justin Collins and Steve Buckland – dated 12 November 2002 @ 11.39am re: “Queensland Hospitals in the 21 st Century: Measured Quality Public and Hospital Reports” - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5429]

Exhibit 339 : Newspaper article – The Courier Mail – dated 4 November 2003 titled “Doctors fear for standards” - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5415]

Exhibit 338 : Newspaper article – The Courier Mail – dated 3 November 2003 titled “Alarm at vetting of overseas doctors” - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5415]

Exhibit 337 : Statement – Dr Stephen Michael BUCKLAND – dated 19 September 2005 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5487]

Exhibit 336 : Statement – Dr Stephen Michael BUCKLAND – dated 16 September 2005 - plus attachments SMB09, SMB10, SMB11, SMB12, SMB13, SMB14, SMB15, SMB16, SMB17, SMB18, SMB19, SMB20, SMB21, SMB22, SMB23, SMB24, SMB25, SMB26, SMB27, SMB28, SMB29, SMB30, SMB31, SMB32, SMB33, SMB34, SMB35, SMB36, SMB37, SMB38, SMB39, SMB40, SMB41, SMB42, SMB43, SMB44, SMB45, SMB46, SMB47, SMB48, SMB49, SMB50, SMB51, SMB52, SMB53, SMB54, SMB55, SMB56, SMB57, SMB58, SMB59, SMB60, SMB61, SMB62, SMB63, SMB64, SMB65, SMB66, SMB67, SMB68, SMB69, SMB69, SMB70, SMB71, SMB72, SMB73, SMB74, SMB75, SMB76, SMB77, SMB78, SMB79, SMB80, SMB81, SMB82, SMB83, SMB84, SMB85, SMB86, SMB87, SMB88, SMB89, SMB90 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5487]

Exhibit 335 : Statement – Dr Stephen Michael BUCKLAND – dated 30 August 2005 - plus attachments SMB-1 to SMB-8 - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5487]

Exhibit 334 : Bundle of Correspondence – preparation of statement/s by Dr Buckland:
(A) Memorandum – Errol Morzone, Counsel Assisting, to Simon Alroe (Minter Ellison) – dated 19 August 2005;
(B) Letter – Richard Douglas SC, Counsel Assisting, to Simon Alroe (Minter Ellison) – dated 30 August 2005;
(C) Letter - Errol Morzone, Counsel Assisting, to Simon Alroe (Minter Ellison) – dated 8 September 2005;
(D) Email - Damien Atkinson, Counsel Assisting, to Simon Alroe (Minter Ellison) – dated 15 September 2005 and attached letter re: measured quality reports
[Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5486]

Exhibit 333 : Letter – Minter Ellison to Commissioner Davies AO – dated 19 September 2005 re: “Our client: Dr Buckland” - [Transcript : 19/09/2005 @ Page 5485]

Exhibit 332 : Draft Minutes – Meeting of Fraser Coast Health Service District of 16 January 2004 - [Transcript : 15/09/2005 @ Page 5466]

Exhibit 331 : Roster – Orthopaedic and Surgical Consultant plus Medical Officer O/Call Roster – Fraser Coast Health Service District – July 2003 - [Transcript : 15/09/2005 @ Page 5460]

Exhibit 330 : Statement – Sean Andrew MULLEN – dated 7 June 2005 - [Transcript : 15/09/2005 @ Page 5446]

Exhibit D : Gilshenan and Luton, Lawyers, dated 14 September 2005 re: calling of witness Mullen - [Transcript : 15/09/2005 @ Page 5439]

Exhibit 329 : Statement – Dale Frances ERWIN-JONES – dated 15 August 2005 including attachments DFE1 to DFE3 - [Transcript : 15/09/2005 @ Page 5397]

Exhibit 328 : Statement – Gary WALKER – dated 14 September 2005 - plus attachments GW1 to GW4, GW5, GW6, GW7-GW18, GW19, GW20-GW22, GW23, GW24-GW26, GW27-GW28, GW29, GW30-GW31, GW32, GW33-GW34 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5387]

Exhibit 327 : Addendum Statement - Michael Carlo ZANCO -dated 14 September 2005 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5387]

Exhibit 326 : Statement – Michael Carlo ZANCO - dated 13 September 2005 plus attachments MCZ1, MCZ2, MCZ3, MCZ4, MCZ5, MCZ6, MCZ7 & MCZ8 and MCZ9 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5386]

Exhibit 325 : Ministerial Briefing – BR022576 - “Treating patients from the elective surgery waiting list” - dated 25 July 2005 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5373]

Exhibit 324 : Correspondence and Memoranda - Analysis of waiting lists – 2005 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5369]

Exhibit 323 : Cabinet Submission – “Attachment 2 - Information Submission to Cabinet on Treating Category 3 Patients from the Elective Surgery Waiting List” - Queensland Health - July 2005 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5369]

Exhibit 322 : Cabinet Submission – Decision No.5900 and Submission No.4639 - “Progress Report on the Waiting List Reduction Strategy” – August 2005 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5369]

Exhibit 321 : Question on Notice – QON No 215 Asked on 27 April 2004 re: waiting times for specialist appointments - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5345]

Exhibit 320 : Briefings - Briefing Folders for the Incoming Minister for Health – Queensland Health – dated 5 February 2004 - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5344]

Exhibit 319 : Statement – Gordon NUTTALL MP – dated 30 August 2005 plus attachments - [Transcript : 14/09/2005 @ Page 5300]

Exhibit 318 : Schedule – Hospital Waiting Lists – dated 1 July 2004 [Transcript : 13/09/2005 @ Page 5256]

Exhibit 317 : Statement – Dr John SCOTT – dated 9 September 2005 plus attachments JGS-1 to JGS-12 & JGS-13 to JGS-18 - [Transcript : 13/09/2005 @ Page 5230]

Exhibit 316 : Instrument of Appointment – Dr John NORTH – by Dr S M Buckland (Acting Director-General) – dated 6 August 2004 - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5170]

Exhibit 315 : Letter – Dr Steve BUCKLAND, then Director-General, QH, to Dr P GIBLIN and DR J NORTH – dated 6 August 2005 - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5159]

Exhibit 314 : Newspaper article – Fraser Coast Chronicle dated 18 January 2003 titled “Richard suffers as Bay waits on surgeon” - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5155]

Exhibit 313 : Schedule – “Orthopaedic Surgical Services – Dr Krishna Scope of Service” by Dr Morgan Naidoo, Director of Orthopaedics, Fraser Coast Health Service District – dated 01 January 2004 - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5142]

Exhibit 312 : Statement – Dr John Bevan NORTH – dated 12 September 2005 - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5126]

Exhibit C : Letter – Clewett, Corser and Drummond, Lawyers, to Hon G Davies AO, Commissioner – dated 9 September 2005 - [Transcript : 12/09/2005 @ Page 5117]

Exhibit B : Letter - Gilshenan and Luton, Lawyers, dated 7 September 2005 - [Transcript : 8/09/2005 @ Page 5110]

Exhibit A : Letter – Gilshenan and Luton, Lawyers, dated 7 September 2005 - [Transcript : 8/09/2005 @ Page 5103]

[Consequent upon the order of the Commissioner, the Honourable G Davies AO, made on 08/09/05, all the evidence taken by the BUNDABERG HOSPITAL COMMISSION OF INQUIRY pursuant to COMMISSIONS OF INQUIRY ORDER (No. 1) 2005, other than the evidence of Mr Leck and Dr Keating and exhibits tendered during their evidence, has been admitted into evidence]

Exhibit 311 : Letter - Mr Peter DWYER to Mr J COWLEY-GRIMMOND - dated 26/08/05 plus Waiting List Reduction Strategy Documents - [Transcript : 26/08/2005 @ Page 5098]

Exhibit 310 : Extracts from the Productivity Commission's Report on Government Services 2005, accompanied by diagram referred to in evidence - [Transcript : 26/08/2005 @ Page 5098]

Exhibit 309 : Questionaire – Public Hospital Report Card, AMAQ – return date 15 September 2000 - [Transcript : 26/08/2005 @ Page 5050]

Exhibit 308 : Statement - Dr Lakshman JAYASEKERA - dated 27/05/05 - [Transcript : 26/08/2005 @ Page 5046]

Exhibit 307 : Statement - Dr Jonathon JOINER - dated 24/06/05 - [Transcript : 26/08/2005 @ Page 5011]

Exhibit 306 : Letter - Mr Peter Dwyer to Mr Cowley-Grimmond - dated 25/08/05 and document : "Number of Patients Waiting for Specialist Outpatients Appointments" - [Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4998]

Exhibit 305 : Press releases - Wendy Edmond, former Minister for Health - from 2000 to 2003 - [Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4933]

Exhibit 304 : Press Release - Wendy Edmond, former Minister for Health - dated 11/11/99 re:Health Minister says Oppositions campaign to discredit the waiting list data is desperate and dishonest - [Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4895]

Exhibit 303 : Press Release - Wendy Edmond, former Minister for Health - dated 30/07/98 re: Health Minister lifts the lid on waiting lists - [Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4895]

Exhibit 302A : Memorandum – Damien ATKINSON, Counsel Assisting to Michael Quinn and Terry Martin SC – dated 19 August 2005
[Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4897]

Exhibit 302 : Statement - Ms Wendy EDMOND - dated 24/08/05 plus attachment - [Transcript : 25/08/2005 @ Page 4872]

Exhibit 301C : Further statement - Dr Michael CLEARY - dated 23/08/05 plus attachments MIC1-MIC3; MIC4; MIC5; MIC6-MIC10; MIC11-MIC15; MIC16; MIC17-MIC18 ; MIC19-MIC22 - “Cardiac Unit Statement” - [Transcript : 23/08/2005 @ Page 4760]

Exhibit 301B : Further Statement – Dr Mark CLEARY – dated 23 August 2005 – plus attachments MC-14 & MC-15 – “Prince Charles Statement” - [Transcript : 23/08/2005 @ Page 4760]

Exhibit 301A : Statement - Dr Michael CLEARY - dated 23/08/05 plus attachments MIC1 to MIC5, MIC6 to MIC13 - “Bundaberg Statement” - [Transcript : 23/08/2005 @ Page 4759]

Exhibit 300 : Statement - Dr Keith McNEIL - dated 22/08/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 23/08/2005 @ Page 4727]

Exhibit 299 : Letter – Hon Premier of Queensland to Commissioner Morris QC – dated 23 August 2005 - [Transcript : 23/08/2005 @ Page 4727]

Exhibit 298 : confidential - [Transcript : 22/08/2005 @ Page 4723]

Exhibit 297 : Statement - Dr David FARLOW - dated 18/08/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 22/08/2005 @ Page 4703]

Exhibit 296 : Letter - Ms Uschi SCHREIBER to Commissioner MORRIS - dated 10/08/05 - [Transcript : 22/08/2005 @ Page 4650]

Exhibit 295 : Statement - Dr Mark WATERS - dated 15/08/05 including attachments MFW1 to MFW11 - [Transcript : 22/08/2005 @ Page 4627]

Exhibit 294 : Statement - Dr James GAFFIELD - dated 01/07/05 plus attachments JWG1 & JWG2 - [Transcript : 19/08/2005 @ Page 4574]

Exhibit 293 : Policy – Queensland Health Integrated Risk Management Policy – Policy Identifier 13355 – dated June 2004 plus superseded version of policy dated 20 February 2002
[Transcript : 19/08/2005 @ Page 4531]

Exhibit 292 : Policy – Queensland Health Complaints Management Policy – dated 23 July 2002 - Policy Identifier 15184 - [Transcript : 19/08/2005 @ Page 4517]

Exhibit 291 : Letter - Mr Stephen ROBERTSON MP to Commissioner MORRIS - dated 17/08/05 - [Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4493]

Exhibit 290C : Statement - Dr John WAKEFIELD - dated 20/07/05 - [Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4487]

Exhibit 290B : Further statement - Dr John WAKEFIELD - dated 16/08/05 plus attachments JGWA to JGWM - [Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4487]

Exhibit 290A : Statement - Dr John WAKEFIELD - dated 16/08/05 plus attachments JGW1 to JGW5, JGW6 to JGW9, JGW10 to JGW12
[Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4487]

Exhibit 289 : Extracts from the medical file relating to P265 - [Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4466]

Exhibit 288 : Letter - Gilshenan and Luton to Dr David ANDREWS - dated 16/08/05 - [Transcript : 18/08/2005 @ Page 4418]

Exhibit 287 : Statement - Ms Joan DOOLEY - dated 16/08/05 - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4413]

Exhibit 286 : Minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District, District Health Council Meeting – dated 25 May 2005 (but referable to 4 May 2005) - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4411]

Exhibit 285C : Minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District, District Health Council Meeting – dated 15 June 2005 - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4410]

Exhibit 285B : Minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District, District Health Council Meeting – dated 25 May 2005 - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4410]

Exhibit 285A : Minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District, District Health Council Meeting – dated 23 March 2005 - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4409]

Exhibit 284 : Affidavit - Mr Vivian CHASE -dated 26/07/05 including attachments VC1 to VC4 - [Transcript : 17/08/2005 @ Page 4373]

Exhibit 283 : Statement - Dr Peter WOODRUFF - dated 15/08/05 plus attachments PWHW1 - PWHW5 - [Transcript : 15/08/2005 @ Page 4269]

Exhibit 282 : Document – Standard for Credentialing and Defining the Scope of Clinical Practice – titled “A National Standard for Credentialing and Defining the Scope of Clinical Practice of Medical Practitioners, for Use in Public & Private Hospitals” – dated July 2004 - [Transcript : 15/08/2005 @ Page 4259]

Exhibit 281 : Memorandum - Mr Peter LECK to Dr Gerry FITZGERALD - dated 19/01/05 plus attachments 1 to 4 - [Transcript : 15/08/2005 @ Page 4255]

Exhibit 280 : "Request to Advertise a Position Form" - dated 31/10/02 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4189]

 

Exhibit 279 : "Queensland Health Policy Statement on Credentials and Clinical Privileges for Medical Practitioners" and"Credentials and Clinical Privileges Guidelines for Medical Practitioners - July 2002" - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4187]

Exhibit 278 : Letter - Dr NYDAM to the Bundaberg Newsmail dated 24/03/05 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4175]

Exhibit 277 : Minutes – Bundaberg Health Service District – FCHSD and BHSD Credentials and Clinical Privileges Committee – dated 26 November 2004 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4144]

Exhibit 276 : Policy – Bundaberg Health Service District, Policy and Procedure Document – “Credentials and Clinical Privileges for Medical Officers - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4144]

Exhibit 275 : Email - Dr PATEL to Dr BETHELL, forwarded by Dr Bethell to Dr NYDAM - dated 13/12/02 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4139]

Exhibit 274 : Email - Dr NYDAM to Dr PATEL - dated 25/02/03 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4135]

Exhibit 273 : Position Description - for Director of Surgery, Bundaberg Health Service District - dated November 2002 - [Transcript : 12/08/2005 @ Page 4112]

Exhibit 272 : Email - Toni HOFFMAN to Dr CARTER dated 30/07/04 showing it was received by Dr CARTER 31/07/04 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4083]

Exhibit 271 : Extract from the patient file of James PHILLIPS - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4070]

Exhibit 270 : Email - Dr KEATING to Dr CARTER - dated 20/08/04 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4069]

Exhibit 269 : Email - Dr Keating to Dr CARTER - dated 10/09/04 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4066]

Exhibit 268 : Radiology reports relating to P44 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4048]

Exhibit 267 : Townsville Health Service District - Number of Patients Waiting plus Queensland Hospital Waiting Lists - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 4002]

Exhibit 266 : Extract - from record of interview of Dr Martin Carter with Crime and Misconduct Commission – 17 May 2005 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 3996]

Exhibit 265A : Report - Bundaberg Base Hospital Department of Medical Imaging - Patient Report Mr Desmond BRAMICH

Exhibit 265 : Statement - Dr Martin CARTER - dated 11/08/05 plus attachments MLC-1 to MLC-7 - [Transcript : 11/08/2005 @ Page 3979]

Exhibit 264 : confidential - [Transcript : 10/08/2005 @ Page 3923]

Exhibit 263 : Statement – Assoc Professor Con ARONEY – undated including attachment CA-1 plus attachments CA-2 to CA-16 - [Transcript : 10/08/2005 @ Page 3923]

Exhibit 262 : Chart – Regular Medications – re: P26 - [Transcript : 10/08/2005 @ Page 3916]

Exhibit 261 : Report – Dr James BOYD re: “Report on issues regarding the care of Desmond Bramich” - [Transcript : 10/08/2005 @ Page 3888]

Exhibit 260c : Further statement - Dr James BOYD including attachment JPB-1 - [Transcript : 9/08/2005 @ Page 3821]

Exhibit 260b : Further statement - Dr James BOYD - dated 20/06/05 - [Transcript : 9/08/2005 @ Page 3821]

Exhibit 260A : Statement - Dr James BOYD - dated 17/06/05 - [Transcript : 9/08/2005 @ Page 3821]

Exhibit 259 : Extract from medical file of Mr Grave - [Transcript : 9/08/2005 @ Page 3815]

Exhibit 258 : Statement - Dr Iftikah Younis - dated 09/08/05 including attachment IY1 - [Transcript : 9/08/2005 @ Page 3774]

Exhibit 257 : Statement - Dr Mark RAY - dated 07/08/05 - [Transcript : 8/08/2005 @ Page 3760]

Exhibit 256 : Statement - Mr Glenn TATHAM - dated 02/06/05 plus attachments GDT1 to GDT 4 - [Transcript : 8/08/2005 @ Page 3736]

Exhibit 255 : Trauma Review Committee material concerning P26 - [Transcript : 8/08/2005 @ Page 3714]

Exhibit 254 : Statement - Dr Jason JENKINS - dated 08/08/05 - [Transcript : 8/08/2005 @ Page 3674]

Exhibit 253 : Letter - Associate Professor BIRKS to Dr Darren KEATING - dated 15/09/03 plus attachments - [Transcript : 5/08/2005 @ Page 3658]

Exhibit 252A : confidential

Exhibit 252 : Statement - Dr Geoffrey de LACY - dated 05/08/05 including attachments GAD1 to GAD4 - [Transcript : 5/08/2005 @ Page 3658]

Exhibit 251 : Statement - Mr Shaun DRUMMOND - dated 02/08/05 - [Transcript : 4/08/2005 @ Page 3573]

Exhibit 250 : Affidavit - Mr Michael DEMY-GEROE - dated 03/08/05 including attachments MDG1 to MDG23 - [Transcript : 4/08/2005 @ Page 3570]

Exhibit 249 : Statement - Mr David SYMMONS - dated 15/07/05 including attachments DADS1 & DADS2 - [Transcript : 4/08/2005 @ Page 3565]

Exhibit 248 : Further statement - Mr Kenneth WHELAN - dated 03/08/05 including attachments KDW1 to KDW3 - [Transcript : 4/08/2005 @ Page 3565]

Exhibit 247 : Statement - Mr Jon GALLAGHER - dated 02/08/05 - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3505]

Exhibit 246 : Letter - Premier to Commissioner MORRIS - dated 03/08/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3489]

Exhibit 245 : Statement - Dr John ALLEN - dated 29/07/05 including attachments JAA1 to JAA4 - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3472]

Exhibit 244 : Report on Bundaberg Intensive Care Services – by Dr D FRAENKEL and Dr C ANSTEY - Central Zone Medical Issues Group – Critical Care Sub-group - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3470]

Exhibit 243 : Statement - Dr Reno ROSSATO - dated 29/07/05 plus attachments RGR1 to RGR3 - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3462]

Exhibit 242 : Statement - Dr Eric Peter GUAZZO - dated 13/07/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 3/08/2005 @ Page 3436]

Exhibit 241 : Statement - Dr Donald Louis MYERS - dated 29/07/05 including attachments DLM1 & DLM2 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3429]

Exhibit 240 : Memorandum - Terry MEHAN to District Managers, Northern Zone - dated 27/06/01 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3417]

 

Exhibit 239 : Queensland Health Investigation File - Mr Victor BERG - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3365]

Exhibit 238 : Medical Board of Queensland file relating
to Mr Victor BERG - Part 1 ; Part 2 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3355]

Exhibit 237 : Further statement - Mr Kenneth WHELAN - dated 14/07/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3355]

Exhibit 236 : Statement - Mr Kenneth WHELAN - dated 29/07/05 including attachments KDW1 to KDW11 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3355]

Exhibit 235 : Email exchange – Lindsay ALLEN to Andrew JOHNSON – between 11 February 2005 @ 11.31pm and 17 February 2005 @ 10.02pm re: ENT services TTH - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3351]

Exhibit 234 : Further statement - Dr Andrew JOHNSON plus attachments AJJ1 to AJJ4, AJJ5 to AJJ9, AJJ10 & AJJ11, AJJ12, AJJ13 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3326]

Exhibit 233 : Statement - Dr Andrew JOHNSON - dated 13 July 2005 - [Transcript : 2/08/2005 @ Page 3325]

Exhibit 232 : Statement – Dr Thomas Martin STRAHAN plus attachments TMS1 to TMS4 - [Transcript : 1/08/2005 @ Page 3252]

Exhibit 231 :
(A) Clinical Services Capability Framework - dated July 2004
(B) Guide to the Role Delineation of Health Services - dated December 1994
(C) Guidelines for Clinical Services in Private Health Facilities - dated 30 November 2002
Transcript : 29/07/2005 @ Page 3245]

Exhibit 230 : Report - Clinical Audit of General Surgical Services Bundaberg Base Hospital dated March 2005 – prepared by Dr FITZGERALD & Mrs JENKINS - [Transcript : 29/07/2005 @ Page 3215]

Exhibit 229 : Letter – Dr COHN to Dr BUCKLAND dated 23 March 2005, including originating letter from Dr BUCKLAND to Mr O’DEMPSEY dated 9 March 2005 - [Transcript : 29/07/2005 @ Page 3211]

Exhibit 228 : Note - concerning Dr NYDAM'S remarks to Commissioner MORRIS - [Transcript : 29/07/2005 @ Page 3191]

Exhibit 227 : Further statement - Dr Gerry FITZGERALD - dated 23/06/05 - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3145]

Exhibit 226 : Further statement - Dr Gerry FITZGERALD - dated 20/06/05 - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3144]

Exhibit 225 : Statement - Dr Gerry FITZGERALD - dated 02/06/05 plus attachments GF1 to GF7, GF8 to GF18, GF19 to GF21, GF22 to GF30, GF31 to GF32 - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3144]

Exhibit 224 : Letter – Commissioner Morris QC to the Clerk of the Parliament – dated 28 July 2005 re: Parliamentary Privilege - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3143]

Exhibit 223 : Letter – Commissioner Morris QC to the Premier of Queensland – dated 28 July 2005 re: Progress of the Inquiry - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3143]

Exhibit 222 : Reports - CT report dated 10 December and histopathology report dated 22 December 2004 , both relating to Mr Kemps - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3094]

Exhibit 221 : Statement - Dr Sangeeva KARIYAWASAM - dated 28/07/05 - [Transcript : 28/07/2005 @ Page 3068]

Exhibit 220 : Report – Guide to the Role Delineation of Health Services - NSW Health, Statewide Services Development Branch – September 1999 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 3024]

Exhibit 219 : Report – Oesophagectomy and Whipples Procedures – Bundaberg Health Service District - 1 January 2002 to 31 March 2002 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 3023]

Exhibit 218 : Draft submission of Dr Peter Cook on matters relevant to the terms of reference - dated 31/05/05 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 3023]

Exhibit 217 : reserved

Exhibit 216 : Newsletter for Specialists and General Practitioners from Bundaberg Base Hospital - dated December 2000 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 2993]

Exhibit 215 : Letter - M Demy-Geroe (Medical Board of Queensland) to Dr NANKIVELL – dated 7 September 2004 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 2978]

Exhibit 214 : Article - Faunce, Thomas A. & Bolsin, Stephen N.C. 'Three Australian whisleblowing sagas : lessons for internal and external regulation' (2004) 181 Medical Journal of Australia 44 - [Transcript : 27/07/2005 @ Page 2977]

Exhibit 213 : Letter - Dr E C NANKIVELL and Dr V KANAGARAJAH to Commissioner MORRIS - dated 18/07/05 - [Transcript : 26/07/2005 @ Page 2954]

Exhibit 212 : Statement - Dr Charles NANKIVELL - dated 03/06/05 plus attachments - [Transcript : 26/07/2005 @ Page 2954]

Exhibit 211 : Letter - Dr Steve BUCKLAND to Commissioner MORRIS - dated 18/07/05 and reply from Commissioner MORRIS to Dr BUCKLAND - dated 25/07/05 - [Transcript : 26/07/2005 @ Page 2932]

Exhibit 210 : Statement - Dr Stephen RASHFORD - dated 26/07/05 including attachments SJR1 to SJR4 - [Transcript : 26/07/2005 @ Page 2902]

Exhibit 209 : Statement - Dr Jeannette YOUNG - dated 20/05/05 plus attachments 1 & 2 - [Transcript : 26/07/2005 @ Page 2845]

Exhibit 208 : Letter - Dr David RISSON to Dr Mark RAY - dated 01/01/05 re: P26 - [Transcript : 25/07/2005 @ Page 2828]

Exhibit 207 : Statement - Dr David RISSON - dated 25/07/05 including attachment DCR1 - [Transcript : 25/07/2005 @ Page 2804]

Exhibit 206 :